Turn your skills into a thriving online business generating $8K/month
One of the most common questions I get asked is about the TikTok Shop: “Is it worth it?” Many people are trying to either join TikTok Shop or reach the follower requirement to get in. The truth is, while TikTok Shop can be a valuable part of a monetization strategy, it shouldn’t be the entire strategy. In this blog post, I will share my insights into why relying solely on TikTok Shop might not be the best approach for your business.
Why TikTok Shop Should Not Be Your Main Strategy
1. Lack of Access to Customer Data
The most important thing for a business is data. Companies like Netflix, Spotify, and TikTok collect extensive customer data, and this information helps them make better decisions, gain more followers, and improve their services. As a business owner, you should focus on collecting names, emails, and purchase information because data is power.
One major downside of TikTok Shop is that you don’t get access to any customer data when someone buys from you. TikTok collects the data, and they use it to boost their own algorithm and sell more products. If you want to be considered a real business, you need data to back up your decisions. Having a mailing list of customers gives you leverage and the ability to market effectively in the future.
2. Dependency on TikTok’s Platform
Another critical issue is that your entire business relies on TikTok. I’ve experienced firsthand the downside of this dependency—I used to have a TikTok Shop where I sold neck massagers. One day, I woke up, and my account was closed without explanation. My business was entirely at the mercy of TikTok’s policies and decisions, and there was no way to get it back.
If your business is 100% dependent on TikTok, you are risking everything. Imagine if McDonald’s relied solely on Subway for their business; they would be in trouble. TikTok’s policies can change, accounts can get flagged, and shops can be closed randomly. Having a business that relies on a third party to this extent is risky.
3. Limitations of the Dropshipping Model
A lot of people are essentially dropshipping from China or even Amazon using TikTok Shop. While the dropshipping business model can work, it comes with challenges. People today expect to receive their products within a day or two, and if you are dropshipping with long shipping times, customers will get frustrated and ask for refunds.
Another issue is that people often promote TikTok Shop as a way to get “free samples.” In reality, this practice can fall into legal gray areas like tax evasion. It’s important to understand the pitfalls of dropshipping if you’re considering this model for TikTok Shop.
Other Challenges of Using TikTok Shop
1. Random Account Closures
Random shop closures are a major issue with TikTok Shop. For example, you could partner with a company, and if their shop is suddenly closed, any link to their products becomes useless. Unlike other affiliate programs, TikTok doesn’t allow you to easily update or replace broken links, which can result in a significant loss of sales.
2. Commission Changes Without Warning
Another downside is that companies partnered with TikTok Shop can change commission rates at any time. You may go from earning $3.99 per sale to $0.97, and you have no control over it. Unlike Amazon, which provides heads-up on commission changes, TikTok does not always offer such transparency.
3. Limited Affiliate Commissions
With Amazon’s affiliate program, if someone clicks on your link and buys other items, you earn a commission on all of them. TikTok Shop, however, only provides commission on the one item clicked. This means you’re leaving potential revenue on the table compared to other affiliate options.
TikTok Shop as Part of a Bigger Strategy
1. Build Your Brand Beyond TikTok
TikTok Shop should be just one part of your monetization strategy. The real secret to long-term success is to build a brand that stands out and isn’t solely dependent on TikTok. This means creating other content, building a relationship with your audience, and promoting other products beyond TikTok Shop.
A good example is combining TikTok Shop with email marketing. Use TikTok to create engaging content that encourages people to join your mailing list. When you have their emails, you can communicate with your audience directly, even when platforms change or accounts are closed. This approach helps ensure that your business doesn’t collapse if one stream of income is cut off.
2. Balance Content Types
To be successful, you need to make TikTok Shop content part of your regular content, not the entirety of it. The most successful creators mix TikTok Shop promotions with their usual engaging content. For example, they may post five videos, where two are promoting TikTok Shop products, and the other three focus on building relationships and engaging their audience.
People want to buy things, but they don’t want to feel like they’re being sold to constantly. To avoid coming across as a salesperson, focus on building trust first, and then sprinkle in your promotional content. The goal is to be authentic and approachable, not like the Home Shopping Network.
Final Thoughts: Is TikTok Shop Worth It?
TikTok Shop can be a useful tool for monetization, but relying solely on it is risky. You need to build a broader strategy that includes collecting data, promoting other streams of income, and balancing promotional content with relationship-building content. People want to connect with you as a person, not just see you push products all the time.
Make TikTok Shop a part of your business, but not the entire business. Grow your email list, engage with your audience, and diversify your income streams so that you aren’t dependent on one platform. Ultimately, a well-rounded strategy will be more resilient and successful in the long term.